Who Asked Would You Eat Them In A Box Would You Eat Them With A Fox Crossword Clue

admin

You need 4 min read

·

Post on Jan 14, 2025

82 visitor like this post

Share

Unlocking the Enigma: "Who Asked Would You Eat Them in a Box, Would You Eat Them with a Fox?" – A Crossword Clue Deep Dive

This seemingly whimsical crossword clue, "Who asked would you eat them in a box, would you eat them with a fox," is far more complex than it initially appears. It's a cryptic clue, relying on wordplay and lateral thinking rather than a direct definition. Solving it requires understanding its literary origins and the clever construction used to obfuscate the answer. This article will delve into the solution, explore the linguistic mechanisms involved, and examine why this clue is so effective (and potentially frustrating!) for crossword enthusiasts.

Deconstructing the Clue:

The clue's brilliance lies in its use of allusion. It doesn't directly ask for a name or a word; instead, it references a well-known children's rhyme that contains the answer within its text. The rhyme, of course, is "Who Asked?" (sometimes also referred to as the "Who Knows?" rhyme), which incorporates the lines:

"Who asked would you eat them in a box? Who asked would you eat them with a fox?"

These lines, deliberately out of context in the crossword clue, act as a disguised definition. The clue writer is not asking you if you would eat something in a box or with a fox. The question is rhetorical, drawing attention to the source of the quoted lines themselves – the rhyme's title, or a variation thereof.

The Answer: "WHO ASKED" (or variations)

The most straightforward answer is simply "WHO ASKED." However, depending on the crossword's word count and grid constraints, variations might be acceptable. For example, "WHO KNOWS" (a common alternative phrasing of the rhyme's title) could also work. The clue's construction allows for this flexibility.

Why This Clue Works (and Why It's Challenging):

• Allusion and Wordplay: Cryptic crossword clues frequently utilize allusion and wordplay. This clue is a masterclass in both. The allusion to the children's rhyme is cleverly disguised within a seemingly nonsensical question.

• Misdirection: The phrasing is deliberately misleading. The reader initially focuses on the surreal imagery of eating something with a fox, leading them away from the true meaning. This creates a sense of challenge and intellectual reward upon solving.

• Cryptic Conciseness: The clue is remarkably concise, packing a great deal of information into a few words. This is a hallmark of high-quality cryptic clues.

• Difficulty Level: This clue is likely positioned towards intermediate or advanced solvers. It requires a broader knowledge of literature and a familiarity with cryptic clue construction techniques. Beginners might find it immensely frustrating, while experienced solvers will find it intellectually stimulating.

• Ambiguity and Precision: While there's a degree of ambiguity in the potential answer ("WHO ASKED" or "WHO KNOWS"), the clue is precise enough to guide solvers toward the correct solution. The rhyme's iconic opening lines provide a clear anchor point.

Expanding on the "Who Asked?" Rhyme:

The "Who Asked?" rhyme, often found in collections of children's rhymes or nursery rhymes, is typically short and nonsensical. Its origins are obscure, lacking a definitive author or origin date. Its enduring popularity stems from its repetitive structure, playful imagery, and nonsensical nature. It's the perfect candidate for a cryptic crossword clue precisely because of its familiarity and inherent oddity.

SEO Keywords and Optimization:

To improve the SEO ranking of this article, it's crucial to incorporate relevant keywords throughout the text. These keywords should target search terms users might use to find information about cryptic crossword clues, children's rhymes, and word puzzle solutions. Here are some relevant keywords and phrases:

• Cryptic crossword clues
• Crossword puzzle solutions
• Who asked would you eat them in a box crossword clue
• Who knows crossword clue
• Cryptic clue examples
• Children's rhymes
• Nursery rhymes
• Wordplay
• Literary allusions
• Crossword puzzle solving techniques

Conclusion:

The crossword clue "Who asked would you eat them in a box, would you eat them with a fox" exemplifies the art of cryptic clue construction. Its use of allusion, misdirection, and wordplay makes it both challenging and rewarding to solve. By understanding the underlying rhyme and the techniques used to obfuscate the answer, solvers can gain a deeper appreciation for the complexity and artistry of cryptic crosswords. This exploration demonstrates how a seemingly simple clue can be a gateway to a world of literary and linguistic intrigue. The answer, "WHO ASKED" (or a variation), is not just a word, it's a key that unlocks a rich tapestry of playful language and clever wordplay.